Tineo home

Settings

How do you compare the cost of two itineraries?

Tineo Editorial Team Last updated 6 min read

You compare the cost of two itineraries by putting them on the same cap, the same categories, and the same kind of number. Write the decision in one sentence, copy every line it does not change, and quote the lines it does change. Compare quote with quote, and read the total after those lines are filled. Dividing by days hides which category moved, because the longer trip contains those extra days on purpose.

Name the decision before you price it

“Train overnight, or a flight plus a hotel night.” “Three cities in this order, or the same cities in another order.” “One rental for the week, or hotels plus local transit.” Each sentence tells you which lines must be requoted and which lines you should copy so you do not invent a fresh guess on the side you secretly prefer.

City order is a transport decision. A fare for one order is a different product from a fare for another, as how to order cities on a trip and how multi-city flight routing works describe. Price the order you would fly. Rerun the meal and local-transport counts only for days the decision changes.

Use the categories on the travel budget planner: transport, lodging, local transit, food, activities, documents, insurance, and contingency. A line that does not fit still gets a home, so the two sheets cannot hide money in a private ninth pile. Documents and insurance often copy straight across. Contingency might not. A tighter connection, a non-refundable room, or a self-booked transfer can change the residual you would pay if the day breaks. Size that residual with how big a trip emergency buffer, once per itinerary, from the events that itinerary creates. A copied buffer hides a risk the decision just added.

Compare like with like

A quote may be compared with a quote. A guess may be compared with a guess only to see that you have been consistent, not to crown a winner. A quote beside a guess means one sheet is unfinished. Go get the missing quote, or leave that category out of the decision and say so. The habit of letting the quoted side look expensive and the guessed side look cheap is how a spreadsheet flatters the trip you have not priced.

Mark status on every line: guess, quoted, or booked. Why trip budgets break is the rule that a quote retires a guess inside one trip. Across two trips, the same rule says the comparison uses the best status you have on both sides. If one hotel is booked and the other is a quote from today, you are comparing a commitment with an offer that can still move. Note that. The booked line is sunk if you keep that itinerary and a penalty if you abandon it. The penalty belongs in the comparison, taken from the cancellation terms, not ignored because the room “was a good price.” How lodging cancellation policies work is where the penalty is defined. The comparison needs the amount you would actually forfeit.

Read what the quote includes. A lodging total that leaves out a mandatory charge is not comparable to a lodging total that includes one, until you have built both lines the way hotel fees after the nightly rate describes. A flight that ends at the terminal is not comparable to a flight sold with a transfer until the missing transfer is a line on the first sheet. Two totals with different contents are two different trips, even when the headers match.

Keep one currency rule for both sheets

If both itineraries are already in your home currency, compare the home-currency lines. If a seller prices in another currency, keep that amount on the line and translate it with a rate you name and date. Use the same rate and the same date on both sheets when both need a translation, so the comparison does not also contain a rate change.

For euro prices, the European Central Bank’s reference rates are one named source. The ECB says the rates are published for information only and strongly discourages using them as transaction rates. Write “reference only,” and keep the gap your card may add, as the budget page describes. The gap can be the same on both sheets when the same card would pay both. It should differ if one itinerary is charged in home currency and the other is not, because only one of them picks up the issuer fee in how card foreign-transaction fees work. This page still does not supply that fee. Copy it from the agreement, or leave the gap unlabeled by any percent.

A posted charge replaces a translation after you book. Until you choose, both sheets stay quotes. Booking one side to “see the real price” ends the comparison and starts a penalty question on the side you might drop.

An illustrative pair of sheets

Every unit below is illustrative. It is not a fare, a hotel rate, a meal price, or a difference you should expect on a real route.

The decision sentence is: overnight train, or a flight plus one hotel night, same destination, same cap of 2,000. Lines that do not change are copied: food guess 200, local transit guess 40, documents 0, insurance quote 30 on both. Contingency is sized from residuals. On the train, the only residual you wrote is a labeled 50. On the flight, an extra night if the flight moves is a labeled 70, and you are using the largest-residual rule, so contingency is 70.

Train sheet, quoted: transport 300, lodging 500. Flight sheet, quoted: transport 450, lodging 400. Quoted subtotal, train 800, flight 850. Copied guesses do not decide anything, because they match. Insurance matches. The contingency difference is 20, from the method, and it is labeled as residuals rather than as a percent of 2,000. Full illustrative totals: train 800 + 200 + 40 + 30 + 50 = 1,120. Flight 850 + 200 + 40 + 30 + 70 = 1,190. Both fit under 2,000. The flight’s transport quote is 150 higher and its lodging quote is 100 lower, so the quoted subtotal is 50 higher. The flight also carries 20 more contingency because you wrote a larger residual.

You may still choose the flight. The sheets show the price of that choice in these units. Both options cover the same days, so a per-day figure would shrink both totals by the same divisor.

If the flight’s lodging line had been a guess of 400 and the train’s lodging were a quote of 500, you would not conclude the flight is cheaper to sleep. You would quote the flight’s hotel, then compare. Until that quote exists, the lodging category is unknown on one side, and the decision rests on the lines that are quotes, or it waits.

Choose, then keep one sheet

Keep the sheet you chose and archive the other so its guesses cannot re-enter the total. Replace each quote with the confirmation amount on the day you book. If a confirmation breaks the cap, the new amount replaces the quote and the difference comes out of contingency or an unlocked line. A poll can record a group’s choice after both sheets are filled. The poll is the decision. The sheets are the prices.

A poll can pick the sheet you keep

Tineo notes can hold both drafts, and a poll on a shared trip can record which itinerary the group chooses. After the choice, forward or paste the confirmations you book to [email protected]. Tineo parses flights, lodging, trains, ferries, transfers, and activities on the sheet you kept. Connecting Gmail is optional. The other draft stays a note. The worksheet you continue is the travel budget planner, with one cap and the lines you actually booked.

Frequently asked questions

How do I compare the cost of two possible trips?

Write the decision in one sentence, then build two sheets with the same categories and the same cap. Copy every line the decision does not change. Get quotes for the lines it does change, and compare those quotes.

Can I compare a quoted flight with a guessed flight?

You can see that one side is unfinished. You cannot treat the difference as a reason to choose. Finish the missing quote, or mark that category as unknown and decide on the categories where both numbers are quotes.

Should I pick the itinerary with the lower cost per day?

Compare the trip totals to the same cap, and compare the categories the decision actually changes. Dividing by days charges the longer trip for days you already wanted, and it mixes quoted lines with guesses.

What if the two itineraries are priced in different currencies?

Translate both with the same named reference rate and the same date, keep each original currency on its line, and leave the card-rate gap the budget page describes. The European Central Bank's euro reference rates are for information only. The posted charge later replaces the translation.

Sources